Buy in store or Online!
Stop by our Babylon or Patchogue, NY locations, or other retailers!
Here is how to shop online:
You can place an order anytime on our website, however, the shipping date depends on what day of the week you place your order. Orders for the week close on Tuesdays at 9am. If you order after that time and day, your order
Buy in store or Online!
Stop by our Babylon or Patchogue, NY locations, or other retailers!
Here is how to shop online:
You can place an order anytime on our website, however, the shipping date depends on what day of the week you place your order. Orders for the week close on Tuesdays at 9am. If you order after that time and day, your order will be shipped out the following week.
We ship out once a week on THURSDAY'S-FRIDAY'S, using USPS. Shipping time varies on where you are ordering from.
Please note: Our cookie pies are made to order, which means they take a week to prepare and ship
*Currently only available to ship within the United States*
*Scroll to the bottom of the page to see where we sell them locally on Long Island!*
If you prefer solid cookies:
You can certainly eat the cookie pies as soon as you open them, or when they reach room temperature after being taken out of the refrigerator.
Warm & Gooey Cookies:
Oven/Air Fryer: Heat until it is at your desired temperature.
(For small= 3-5 minutes at 350 degrees F)
(For large= 4-7 minutes at 350 degrees F)
Mic
If you prefer solid cookies:
You can certainly eat the cookie pies as soon as you open them, or when they reach room temperature after being taken out of the refrigerator.
Warm & Gooey Cookies:
Oven/Air Fryer: Heat until it is at your desired temperature.
(For small= 3-5 minutes at 350 degrees F)
(For large= 4-7 minutes at 350 degrees F)
Microwave: Place cookie pie in tin in the center of the microwave, and heat until it reaches your desired temperature (10-30 seconds depending on size)
It can overcook easily in the microwave so keep an eye on it!
DO NOT put plastic lid into the microwave. They are not microwaveable. Aluminum tin is microwavable when placed in center of the microwave.
Want to save them for another day?
Cookie pies stay fresh for three weeks in room temperature when they are delivered.
They are best when kept in the refrigerator to preserve freshness. Putting them in the refrigerator will make them last up to four weeks!
Freezing them will allow them to stay fresh for up to four months.
By choosing the shipping option, you are agreeing to our policy that Baked with Grace is NOT responsible for missing/delayed/wrong address items that are in the mail carriers care. Once they leave our facility and are shipped, they are NOT in our control.
Each Package takes around a week to prepare and ship.
We ship out once a week on THURSDAY'S-FRIDAY'S, using USPS.
*Currently only available to ship within the United States*
*WE ARE NOT RESPONSIBLE FOR DELAYED/LOST PACKAGES THROUGH USPS, CONTACT THEM DIRECTLY WITH PROBLEMS*
BAKED WITH GRACE
65 Deer Park Ave Babylon, NY 11702
Check our Contact Us page for hours
Here is how you can pick them up:
-Go up to the counter and ask for your Baked with Grace Order
-Tell them the name of the order, and they will get your cookie pies!
*If you choose this option, you MUST pick them up within a week. After then, they will be thrown out*
We will deliver right to your house! If your address is within a 15 mile radius of our store, you can place an order for online delivery! We are in Babylon, so we will go as far as:
West= Wantagh
North= Huntington
East= Patchogue
Anything within those boundaries is accepted! If you are out of those boundaries, you can call or email us for a price on how much it would be additional to deliver it. These orders also come with an order minimum of $50. Unfortunately, if you live out of those boundaries, do not meet our order minimum, and do not wish to pay an extra fee for delivery, we cannot hand deliver. Instead, we would be able to ship them through USPS!
-USPS did not deliver your order in time: By choosing the shipping option when purchasing, you agreed to understand that any problems with USPS are out of Baked with Grace's control. We state on our website that each package is shipped out the following Thursday/Friday after the order is placed. You can either send with Priority Mail or Express Mail, and express is the only one that is guaranteed a certain delivery date by USPS. When placing an order, it is best to keep that in mind. We cannot control USPS and when they deliver your package. If you need a shipment to come before an event on a specific day, order the cookie pies the week prior. That will result in the cookies being there on time, and they stay fresh for: three weeks room temperature, four weeks in the refrigerator, and up to four months in the freezer.
-USPS States your order was delivered, but it is not at your address: After your order leaves our facility, it is under the care of USPS. By choosing the shipping option when purchasing, you agreed to understand that any problems with USPS are out of Baked with Grace's control. We will be glad to assist you with any problems, but are not able to give any refunds or resend any packages. When you check your shipping information and USPS has stated your package has been delivered, that means that your package has been scanned at your address and left for you to receive. If anything happens to your package after that, it is completely out of Baked with Grace and USPS control. We are not responsible for stolen or lost packages after they have been delivered. If you have proof that the package was never delivered, your best option is to contact your local postal office, either in person or on the phone, and tell them about the situation. If it is their problem and your package is lost, they have an option where you are able to get a refund.
-Shipping box ruined from animal destroying it: Although we apologize for this, we are in no way responsible for animals getting into your box. Once your package is delivered, it is completely out of our control. This circumstance does not receive a refund.
-Writing the wrong address in for where the order will be shipped to: It is not our responsibility to make sure the address written is correct. We use a third party website that gathers the orders from GoDaddy and creates the shipping labels for us. As a result, we will always send out each order with the address that the customer has provided. It is the customers responsibility to provide an address that is correct, and that USPS can deliver correctly. If it is not written correctly, USPS will ship it back to our facility. Because of this, no full refunds will be given, since our products and shipping expenses were wasted.
-Canceling an order after the first 24 hours it was placed: Our cookie pies are made to order. This means that once someone places an order, we track how many cookie pies need to be made and we start the baking process. We do not accept cancelled orders after a specific time, since the cookie pies will already be in the baking process.
-
We want to make sure our customers have a great experience while doing business with us. If you have any questions or concerns, please contact us by leaving a message in the Contact Us section or emailing us at contact@bakedwithgraceny.com
Copyright © 2022 Baked with Grace - All Rights Reserved.
Powered by GoDaddy Website Builder
We use cookies to analyze website traffic and optimize your website experience. By accepting our use of cookies, your data will be aggregated with all other user data.